Thread
Printable Version

Grey's Anatomy Season 9-11 General Discussion Thread (Spoilers)

TOP

Don't Dream It's Over

At least he had guts to face her at the end . Looking at promos it doesn't look promising

TOP

11x17 With or Without You

This series is so predictable i think it obvious she will follow him to Settle but i am glad Derek stop from cheating on his wife and willing to make it work but they are seriously running out of storyline

TOP

TOP

TOP

11x18 When I Grow Up

Asking mother of the cop to donate his organ to his killer was awful but bailey really pushing it was great despite the fact everyone had given up on him

TOP

TOP

TOP

11x20 One Flight Down

That was great misdirect in promo thinking it was Derek plane when it was just random plane but Webber seeing the plane crash was lucky as he managed to get them ready for it

TOP

11x21 How to Save a Life

If you have not watch this episode can you please stop reading now, This is spoiler review  

There has been a lots of angry comments regarding this episode because death of a major character is tough but kill him like that was cruel and so ironic. This character has been on the show from start 11 years is a long time and he is beloved character so the fact he saved 3 people from car crash was nice way to end his life but of all bad luck being transport to inadequate hospital with inexperience doctor was awful. He did deserved a better exit than that.

Medieth dealing with the situation was well done but I can't believe she had to give a teaching lecture to the doctor who killed her husband . She was very understanding about it but much more composted than I expected her to be consider she just lost her husband.

TOP

Reply 210#210 bala's post

Through the years Meredith has proven she doesn't deal with her emotions well.  It will take her awhile before she even understands the depth of her grief.  I agree with you about his exit.  It was Lazy and lame.  Saving the people were awesome but a semi truck going...How fast on the heals of a cleaned area after another accident??  Going to a hospital that doesn't deal with traumas?   It's either a great way to introduce new characters or it was just LAZY.  I hope Meredith wants to "adopt" the lame hospital and giving it some teaching.   

I can now in good conscience, walk away from Grey's.  I need to cut some of my shows next year and this will be a great ending.  
I'm not afraid of tomorrow, for I have seen yesterday and I love today.

TOP

Reply 210#210 bala's post

Thank you for posting such a noticeable message that your post contains spoilers, Bala.  I have seen the episode, but someone spoiled it for me last night, and I was not a happy camper.  

I did not like this exit either, but thinking about it, death was really the only realistic way to write him out and stay true to his character.  It could have been done better though.  
Remember to KISS......Keep It Simple Stupid!

TOP

Reply 212#212 waterlilybarb's post

With the amount of posting i do i know it's easy to think none of my comment contains spoilers as i try my best to be vague in my comment but there was no way i could be vague about that character dying.  

Glad you appeciate it

TOP

Reply 211#211 arksongbird80's post

Trust me you won't be able to walk away because at some point in the future you hear something that will make you come back to the show

TOP

Reply 214#214 bala's post

NOOOOOOOOOOO!!!  I refuse.  I have a bunch of Shows I want to walk away from.   That would make a great thread.....,
I'm not afraid of tomorrow, for I have seen yesterday and I love today.

TOP

Reply 215#215 arksongbird80's post

I know how you feel i tried walk away from shows but i eventually end up catch up



[ Last edited by bala at 4-26-2015 09:02 ]

TOP

TOP

11x22 She's Leaving Home

I haven’t done a TV RANT for ages and this extended 90 minute episode deserve a rant because it really made me angry as a fan and looking at other fans, their reaction is the same as mine. What should have been a sad episode was belittled by only flashbacks which show a lack of respect for Derek Shepard not only that, the fact that they skip the funeral and move on during the 90 minutes was crazy. They didn't even spend 5 minutes for his funeral . It’s so hard not to swear on this bloody forum.

Please don't get me wrong this was classic Grey's anatomy episode if Derek hadn't died I would though this would been great episode but the fact they decided to extended episode focus Meredith not only running away but later to reveal she's pregnant with Derek child was crazy,

The best storyline was burn's patient case that was very sad. I am  glad April return unharmed.

TOP

I was in New York when the How to Save a Life aired. I didn't get to watch it live as we were out that night. But my friend text me to say don't look at Facebook or go online until you watch it. So although I didn't know, I had a feeling. There were some hints from the previous episodes.

I was very angry with Shonda Rhimes for writing Patrick Dempsey out of it. Now I'm hearing that there was tension between the pair off camera. I wonder if Shonda is the common factor here now seeing as she's written a few people out due to creative differences, hmm. Not sure, that could all be smoke and mirrors, who knows.

I'm with you Arksongbird. I've decided that after watching She's Leaving Home that I'm happy to leave the show right there and move on. Grey's, The Good Wife and Blue Bloods are 3 of the long running shows I always look forward to watching. And now it's probaby really just Blue Bloods. I think The Good Wife lost focus with Will's death. I didn't want to believe it and stuck with the show, but it's lost it's appeal for me. Much the same way I feel Grey's will too.

It's a shame, but it had a good run.

TOP

Reply 219#219 shinny's post

It has a good run but i still don't think it needs any of original cast members for the show to continue just look at the last episode Meredith left for almost 1/2 the episode i didn't even miss her at all .

I would be happy if this would been final season but i have feeling Shonda Rhimes won't let this show die since this is her only hospital show out of 3 she's done and she too proud to end the show. As along ABC give her money she will continue.

TOP

Thread